A Blog for moth recorders in Bucks, Berks and Oxon
Pages
▼
Friday, 23 October 2020
Chestnuts Again ......
Apologies for monopolising the Blog.
Using John Thacker's helpful reply to an earlier post this week, I've attempted to apply his criteria to identify top as Dark Chestnut and lower, Chestnut. But I could be wrong, seems they are very tricky.
They are tricky, and there will be some specimens that are not readily classifiable (see also discussion in: https://www.birdguides.com/articles/invertebrates/moths-of-the-season-challenging-chestnuts), especially for those of us who rely mainly on photos for identification. In my view also, the first moth you show is most likely a Chestnut from its slightly rounded wing apex and termen, etc. Despite the English names, colour is not always a guide, as also nicely illustrated recently in a tweet from Steve Nash (https://twitter.com/SteveNash71/status/1319681447096176641/photo/1).
I'm afraid they both look like Chestnut to me, Nic.
ReplyDeleteMany thanks Dave. I've been looking at lots of reference and was coming to that conclusion I think!
ReplyDeleteRegards,
Nic.
They are tricky, and there will be some specimens that are not readily classifiable (see also discussion in: https://www.birdguides.com/articles/invertebrates/moths-of-the-season-challenging-chestnuts), especially for those of us who rely mainly on photos for identification. In my view also, the first moth you show is most likely a Chestnut from its slightly rounded wing apex and termen, etc. Despite the English names, colour is not always a guide, as also nicely illustrated recently in a tweet from Steve Nash (https://twitter.com/SteveNash71/status/1319681447096176641/photo/1).
ReplyDeleteThanks John, appreciate your help and especially the two links.
DeleteRegards,
Nic.